I agree about the SynBad and SilkSmoke (both of which I have binned), but my experiments with the G5A have shown it is a real knot, and the earlier ones bear no comparison at all. The G5A splays progressively, not all at once, unlike most synthetics. Its only drawback is that it could do with being just a little longer...I'd love to grab a G5C myself but was put off by the fact that of the AP Shave Co knots I've tried (Faux Horse, SynBad, SilkSmoke) the Faux Horse is the only one I enjoy as they're all quite long bristled requiring them to be set deep otherwise way too much splay for my liking. On top of the $$$ for shipping and time it takes to arrive from Canada I was less inclined to go back which is a shame as reading good things about the G5 range.YMMV